Javascript must be enabled for the correct page display

Contextualizing Al-nafs: A Critique of Badri’s Historical Account of Islamic Psychology

Aldabbagh, Joud (2023) Contextualizing Al-nafs: A Critique of Badri’s Historical Account of Islamic Psychology. Master thesis, Psychology.

[img]
Preview
Text
JOUD MT FINAL - CONTEXTUALIZING AL-NAFS (2).pdf

Download (461kB) | Preview

A thesis is an aptitude test for students. The approval of the thesis is proof that the student has sufficient research and reporting skills to graduate but does not guarantee the quality of the research and the results of the research as such, and the thesis is therefore not necessarily suitable to be used as an academic source to refer to. If you would like to know more about the research discussed in this thesis and any publications based on it, to which you could refer, please contact the supervisor mentioned.


Abstract

The movement toward indigenizing psychology within an Islamic context has ignited controversies among historians of psychology regarding the discipline's purported origins in the Islamic Golden Age. Malik Badri, a prominent figure in the Islamic Psychology subfield, claims that Persian Muslim polymath Abu Zayd Al-Balkhi pioneered CBT in the 9th century. However, Badri neglects to contextualize a key concept within Al-Balkhi’s manuscript and Islamic Psychology at large, al-nafs, by equating it with the terms “psyche and “mind.” In the current study, I explore the historical narratives of mental health paradigms from the Islamic Golden Age in order to contextualize the meaning of al-nafs, differentiating it from the mind and psyche. This historical analysis forms the foundation for addressing historiographical disputes and evaluating the most valuable approach when conducting a history of Islamic Psychology. The study also aims to contextualize Badri’s inclination for making priority claims by establishing a conceptual framework for his approach to Islamizing psychology. The findings reveal the continuity of al-nafs from medieval Muslim philosophy, particularly Al-Ghazali’s typology of the Islamic soul, to present-day mental health explanatory models among Muslim scholars and spiritual practitioners. Given this intellectual lineage, I suggest that future studies adopt a two-pronged approach: a social historiography to deepen understanding of the meaning behind al-nafs as it was conceived by early Muslim scholars like Al-Balkhi and Al-Ghazali, alongside a philosophical and intellectual history of Islamic Psychology that contextualizes the development of al-nafs and the emergence of an Islamic epistemological psychology paradigm.

Item Type: Thesis (Master)
Supervisor name: Mulberger Rogele, A.C. and Burman, J.T.
Degree programme: Psychology
Differentiation route/Track: Theory and History of Psychology [Master Psychology]
Date Deposited: 30 Aug 2023 10:25
Last Modified: 30 Aug 2023 10:25
URI: http://gmwpublic.studenttheses.ub.rug.nl/id/eprint/2830

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item